Experimental Constraints on the Symmetron Field: Breakthrough Research with Magnetically Levitated Force Sensors

Academic Background

Dark energy is the mysterious force behind the accelerated expansion of the universe, but its essence remains an enigma. To explain the nature of dark energy, scientists have proposed various theories, among which the Symmetron Field Theory is considered a key candidate. This theory predicts a Fifth Force, which interacts with matter but is screened in high-density environments, posing significant challenges for laboratory detection. Although several experiments have constrained parts of the parameter space of the symmetron model, much remains unexplored. Therefore, the research team developed an experimental platform based on a magnetically levitated force sensor to probe the symmetron fifth force at submillimeter scales while minimizing screening effects.

Source of the Paper

This paper was co-authored by Peiran Yin, Xiangyu Xu, Kenan Tian, and others from institutions such as Nanjing University and the University of Science and Technology of China. It was published in Nature Astronomy on December 4, 2024. By improving experimental methods, the research team enhanced the constraints on the symmetron model’s parameter space by six orders of magnitude, demonstrating the substantial potential of this system in exploring forces beyond the Standard Model.

Research Process

1. Design and Construction of the Experimental Platform

The research team designed an experimental platform based on a magnetically levitated force sensor. The platform includes a source mass and a test mass, both placed within a high-vacuum environment (at a pressure of 10⁻⁵ mbar). The source mass consists of 16 uniformly distributed silica films, each 100 micrometers thick, mounted on a rotating disc. The test mass is a 25-micrometer-thick polyimide film suspended on a frame made of three glass rods and precisely positioned using a magnetic levitation system.

To reduce interference from electrostatic and magnetic forces on the fifth-force signal, the research team implemented several shielding measures. The source mass is enclosed in a metal box, with a 200-nanometer-thick gold-plated silicon nitride window at the top to ensure that the symmetron field can penetrate the shield. Additionally, the entire system is equipped with a magnetic shield box to eliminate magnetic forces generated by the source mass.

2. Measurement of the Fifth Force

In the experiment, the source mass disc is rotated at a specific frequency via a servo motor, generating a periodic symmetron field that exerts a periodic fifth force on the test mass. The research team recorded the displacement response of the test mass using an optical system and analyzed the signals in the frequency domain using Fourier transforms.

To optimize the detection of the fifth force, the research team numerically simulated and optimized the geometries of the source and test masses. They chose thicknesses comparable to the Compton wavelength (25 micrometers for the test mass and 100 micrometers for the source mass) to minimize screening effects.

3. Data Calibration and Analysis

The research team calibrated the sensitivity of the force sensor by measuring thermal noise and Newtonian gravity. In the experiment, the resonant frequency of the force sensor was aligned with the drive frequency to maximize the accumulation of the fifth-force signal. By continuously collecting data over 105 seconds, the research team calculated the upper limit of the fifth force and used numerical simulations to constrain the parameter space of the symmetron field.

Main Results

1. Upper Limit of the Fifth Force

At a 95% confidence level, the research team measured the upper limits of the fifth force to be 0.42 fN (d₂ = 0.2 mm) and 0.33 fN (d₂ = 0.3 mm). These results are consistent with the theoretical prediction of Brownian thermal noise, indicating no significant detection of the fifth force.

2. Constraints on the Symmetron Parameter Space

Based on the experimental results, the research team imposed constraints on the parameter space of the symmetron model. Figure 3a shows the excluded regions in the λ–mₛ plane at the dark energy scale (μ = 2.4 MeV). The results indicate that the experiment improved the constraints on the λ parameter space by six orders of magnitude, particularly around mₛ ≈ 10² GeV.

Conclusion and Significance

This study successfully demonstrated the effectiveness of an experimental platform based on a magnetically levitated force sensor in detecting the symmetron fifth force, especially at submilligram scales. This method provides a new perspective for exploring the origin of dark energy and lays the groundwork for further enhancing experimental performance in cryogenic environments. Moreover, this research opens new possibilities for exploring other fundamental physics questions, such as short-range gravity, wave-function collapse models, and quantum gravity.

Research Highlights

1. Innovative Design of the Experimental Platform: The research team designed an experimental platform based on a magnetically levitated force sensor, successfully detecting the fifth force at submillimeter scales through optimized geometry and shielding measures.
2. Significant Expansion of Parameter Space: The experiment improved constraints on the symmetron model’s parameter space by six orders of magnitude, filling gaps left by existing experiments.
3. Multidisciplinary Application Potential: This experimental platform is not only applicable to dark energy research but also to exploring other fundamental physics questions, offering broad application prospects.

Other Valuable Information

The research team provided raw data and numerical simulation codes from the experiment for further analysis and validation by other researchers. Additionally, the paper details the temperature control and vibration isolation systems of the experimental setup, providing important references for designing similar future experiments.

---

Through this research, scientists have not only deepened their understanding of the nature of dark energy but also laid the foundation for detecting unknown forces with higher precision and at lower temperatures in the future. This breakthrough will have a profound impact on the field of physics.